Raised Toilet Seat Vs Bedside Commode: Who Will Win?

When it comes to assisting individuals with mobility issues, choosing the right toilet aid is crucial for comfort, safety, and independence. Two popular options are raised toilet seats and bedside commodes. This comprehensive guide will explore the advantages and disadvantages of each option to help you make an informed decision.

Raised Toilet Seat

Advantages

• Easy to Install: Raised toilet seats are typically quick and easy to install, making them a convenient option.
• Affordable: Compared to bedside commodes, raised toilet seats are generally more affordable.
• Compact: They occupy minimal space, making them suitable for smaller bathrooms.
• Portable: Some raised toilet seats are portable, allowing for easy transportation.

Disadvantages

• Limited Height Adjustment: Most raised toilet seats offer limited height adjustment, which may not be suitable for all users.
• Can be Unstable: If not properly installed or secured, raised toilet seats can become unstable.
• May Require Additional Support: Individuals with severe mobility issues may need additional support, such as grab bars or a transfer bench.

Bedside Commode

Advantages

• Height Adjustability: Bedside commodes offer adjustable heights, allowing users to find the most comfortable and safe position.
• Stability: They are typically more stable than raised toilet seats, providing a secure base for users.
• Built-in Safety Features: Some bedside commodes feature safety features such as armrests, footrests, and splash guards to enhance user comfort and safety.
• Can be Used as a Shower Chair: Many bedside commodes can be converted into shower chairs, providing versatility.

Disadvantages

• Larger Footprint: Bedside commodes require more space than raised toilet seats, making them less suitable for smaller bathrooms.
• More Expensive: They are generally more expensive than raised toilet seats.
• Not Portable: Bedside commodes are not portable, making them less convenient for travel or temporary use.

Choosing the Right Option

The best choice between a raised toilet seat and a bedside commode depends on individual needs and preferences.

Consider the following factors:

• Mobility Level: Individuals with limited mobility may benefit from the stability and height adjustability of a bedside commode.
• Bathroom Size: For smaller bathrooms, a raised toilet seat may be a better space-saving option.
• Budget: If affordability is a concern, a raised toilet seat may be a more suitable choice.
• Versatility: If you need a device that can be used for both toileting and showering, a bedside commode with shower chair functionality is a versatile option.

Installation and Safety

• Installation: Follow the manufacturer’s instructions carefully for proper installation of both raised toilet seats and bedside commodes.
• Safety: Ensure that the device is stable and secure before use. Use grab bars or a transfer bench for additional support if necessary.

Popular Questions

1. Which option is better for individuals with severe mobility issues?
Bedside commodes with adjustable heights and safety features are generally recommended for individuals with severe mobility issues.

2. Can I use a raised toilet seat with my existing toilet?
Yes, raised toilet seats are designed to fit on most standard toilets.

3. How do I choose the right height for a bedside commode?
Adjust the height so that the user’s feet are flat on the floor and their knees are bent at a 90-degree angle.

4. Can I use a bedside commode in a shower?
Yes, some bedside commodes can be converted into shower chairs, providing versatility.

5. How often should I clean my toilet assist device?
Clean the device regularly with a mild disinfectant to maintain hygiene and prevent the spread of germs.